In the City That Never Sleeps, at a time when baseball, football, basketball, and hockey intersect, what animates the five-borough residents most of all during these late October nights are thoughts of the New York Yankees. Whether it be A-Rod’s prodigious blasts, Derek Jeter’s guile, Mariano Rivera’s unhittable cutter, or nightmarish reminders of the collapse of 2004…….it’s the stuff that dreams are made of.
Late season heroics by the Yanks have been on hold for the past five years, but they have been on full display during the past two weeks.
During their three-game sweep of the Twins in the Divisional Playoffs A-Rod hit game-saving homers in games two and three; Jeter lured Twinkie Nick Spanos into a desperate surge ‘round third before calmly throwing him out; and Rivera, by performing to his usual excellence during a week when fellow closers Papelbon, Nathan, Franklin, and Street failed miserably, cemented his standing as the game’s greatest closer.
Against the Angels in the just-concluded ALCS, the Yanks won with pitching and defense and generally outsmarted their past tormentors in convincing 4-2 fashion. The victory was not without its trepidations, however. The Yankees capitalized on Sabathia’s pitching and Angel errors to sprint to a 2-0 lead, but when the Bomber bull pen blew game 5 after storming ahead 6-4 in the top of the seventh, Yank fans started running scared.
The main objects of the scorn were relievers Hughes and Chamberlain, who were hit hard throughout the series, and Manager Girardi, who was charged with felony over-managing.
In Game 3, he relieved David Robertson with two out, nobody on, in the top of the eleventh. Robertson’s substitute Alfredo Aceves promptly relinquished a hard single and a game-winning double. Then in game 5, Girardi pinch ran Freddy Guzman for A-Rod with the Yankees trailing by a run in the eighth. The skipper was also roasted for allowing shaky starter A.J. Burnett to start the seventh.
In the words of Mike Francesa, a “Tension Convention” set in. The Ghosts of 2004 evoked eerie fears of failure among the faithful. So scared were Yankee fans going into game 6 that the ball game drew a “forty share” tv rating to the “eight share” registered by the Giants-Arizona game being played across the river in the Meadowlands.
The fans respect for the Angels was well grounded. With their combination of pesky contact hitters, daring base stealers, tight defense, and brilliant relief pitching, the Angels had managed to defeat the Yankees in two divisional playoffs (2002 and 2005) and five consecutive season series. They were hard to grab hold of, these Angels. Just when you had them down, they’d string three or four base hits in a row to grab the lead.
This year’s Angels, however, did not bring with them their traditional set of demons. For one thing, their indomitable closer, Francisco Rodriguez, now toiled for the Mets. His successor, Brian Fuentes, served up a tying ninth inning homer to A-Rod on an 0-2 pitch which turned game 2.
The Angels never got their running game going because Yankee pitchers stifled Angel table setters Chone Figgins and Bobby Abreu into 7-48 hitting and one stolen base. To top things off, the Halos committed uncharacteristic base running mistakes and made eight errors in the field, including an unforgivable 3-pointer launched by Scott Kazmir over the first baseman’s head on a Yankee bunt in the 8th inning of game six.
The Phillies pose a more tangible set of obstacles. They’ve got power pitchers and a band of sluggers who will pose as much of a threat to the short Yankee Stadium right field porch as the Bombers themselves. They’re not particularly fast, and their manager Charlie Manuel is old school. One through six in the batting order, they’re as strong as anybody in the majors. They’re the defending World Series Champs and have won their last five post season series, going 18-4 in the process.
Position by position, the Phillies stack up reasonably well against the Yankees. Notwithstanding the Phils’ triumvirate of Rollins, Utley and Howard, consisting of two recent mvp’s and the most productive second baseman in baseball, the Yankees hold the edge in the infield. Cano and Teixeira provide far better defense than Utley and Howard; and Jeter and A-Rod destroy Philadelphia’s left side offensively. The guess here is that a Howard miscue at first will figure prominently in a Yankee rally. Posada at catcher outshines the Phils’ Ruiz.
The Phils hold the edge in the outfield. Victorino is brilliant in center field, Werth possesses a powerful throwing arm in right, and Ibanez is better in the field than either Damon or Matsui. At the plate, the Phils are also slightly better, particularly with Swisher slumping.
Which brings us to pitching, where the Phillies have been in a state of flux. Neither the Phils’ rotation nor its bullpen bears much resemblance to the stellar crew which marched through the Brewers, Dodgers, and Tampa Bay a year ago. The only holdover in the rotation is Cole Hamels, last year’s NLCS and World Series mvp, but this year’s question mark. In three post-season starts, his E.R.A is 6.75.
Phils anchor, Cliff Lee, acquired in mid-season from Cleveland, has been unhittable this post-season. Through 20 innings, he’s 3-0 with an unthinkable E.R.A of .74. But the lineups he faced against the Rockies and Dodgers did not contain names like Jeter, Rodriguez, Teixeira and Matsui. Familiar with the left-handed Lee from his days in the American League, this foursome is lifetime 31-83 against him with good power numbers. Lee was a teammate in Cleveland of Yankee powerhouse CC Sabathia; and like CC, he’s a former Cy Young winner, but he does not carry the same warranty.
Pedro Martinez is scheduled to start game two at the Stadium. Martinez was acquired by the Phils in mid-August, did not pitch against Colorado, but twirled seven masterful innings of two-hit ball in game 2 against the Dodgers, who had not faced him during the regular season. The Yanks know Pedro from his seasons with the Red Sox and inter-league play with the Mets. They are unlikely to be so fooled by his off-speed medley as were the free-swinging, youthful Dodgers.
The Yankee starter in game 2 will be A.J. Burnett. Unlike his mentally-steeled teammates, Burnett has a fragile psyche. With runners on base, in a tight situation, Burnett is as likely to throw one in the dirt as on the black. Unlike Andy Pettitte, who manages to wriggle out of situations, Burnett never met an inning he could not mutilate. Game 5 against the Angels is a case in point. After surrendering four runs in the first, he pitched five scoreless, only to melt-down in the critical seventh inning. Nevertheless, he has enough pure stuff to outlast Pedro who will be hard-pressed to enter the sixth against the patient Yankees.
The Phillies have more depth in their rotation than the Yanks, but starters four and five are of little benefit in a seven game series. At the three hole, Pettitte holds the edge over Hamels. Going into the playoffs, the perception was that the Yanks’ bullpen was much better than the Phils’. Following the disappointing performances of Hughes and Chamberlain, and decent efforts by the Phils’ middle against Colorado and L.A., that conclusion is uncertain; but the Yanks hold a clear and convincing advantage with their closer, Rivera, over Brad Lidge.
The Yanks are likely to start left-handers in at least four, and maybe five, of the seven games. This is bad news for Howard, on whom the Phillies are dependent for their run production. Against lefties this season, Howard hit .207 compared to .319 against right-handers. He can be pitched to.
These historic franchises last met in the Fall Classic in 1950, when the Yankees swept the Whiz Kids. The Phils should do better this time.
Yankees in five.

































