Say No to Cano

October 23rd, 2013 sendarama Posted in baseball No Comments »

Entering the off-season, Yankee General Manager Brian Cashman faces decisions which are no less daunting than those faced by Hobson or Sophie.

Having just said farewell to revered Yankee lifers Mariano Rivera and Andy Pettitte (in the exercise of columnist privilege, we will overlook Pettitte’s 3-year stopover in Houston), Cashman must ponder how far he will go to retain free agent second baseman Robinson Cano, who has demanded a ten-year 300 million contract to finish his career in pinstripes.

Cashman’s decision is complicated by the new MLB salary cap rules, which would severely punish the Yanks for exceeding 189 million in payroll for the 2014 season, and by the uncertain status of Alex Rodriguez who may be suspended for all or part of the 2014 season for his involvement with the Biogenesis clinic.

If the arbitrator hearing A-Rod’s case concludes that the 211 game suspension imposed by MLB was justified, or that A-Rod should be set down for 100 games or more, then all or most of A-Rod’s salary comes off the books for 2014 and a Cano signing becomes more likely, particularly if his deal is back-loaded beyond 2014.

But if, as appears probable, the arbitrator’s hearing drags on into the deep winter, or a negotiated resolution with MLB substantially cuts A-Rod’s suspension, then Cashman will get no relief from A-Rod’s predicament.

Eight years into his career, Cano, 31 years old yesterday, is on track to become the most prolific second baseman of the modern era. He is well on his way to surpassing the batting average, home run and rbi totals of Hall of Famers Joe Morgan, Roberto Alomar, and Ryne Sandberg and has a decent shot at reaching Jeff Kent’s record for career home runs by a second baseman (377) and Rogers Hornsby’s lifetime rbi total (1584). He fields his position beautifully and has a rifle for an arm.

Signed by the Yankees as an 18 year old out of the Dominican Republic and raised in their farm system, Cano is poised to join Yankee legends Lou Gehrig, Bill Dickey, Joe Dimaggio, Yogi Berra, Whitey Ford, Mickey Mantle, Derek Jeter, and Rivera, as Hall of Famers who spent their entire major league careers in the Yankee system.

But don’t bet the ranch on it.

What would have been inconceivable during the George Steinbrenner era is a distinct possibility under the management of Cashman and Hank Steinbrenner, George’s more grounded son. Recognizing that the Yanks can be a mediocre team notwithstanding Cano’s brilliance (see 2013) and that their greater need is for young pitching, the Yanks may well determine that they can follow the example set by St. Louis and Boston and allocate the money saved by letting Cano go to stocking young, powerful arms and acquiring 3-4 modestly priced free agents to fill the several holes in their regular lineup.

And that would be the right decision. Because though Cano is a top of the line player, he is a middle of the road teammate.Your highest paid player should set an example for his teammates, but Cano undermines team spirit by his failure to expend maximum effort and by a seemingly lackadaisical attitude. The game comes so easily to him that he appears not to be trying. On grounders to the right side, he lopes lazily to first base. In the field, he waits ’til the last second to throw out the runner. He is simply not programmed to be a team leader.

The Cardinals and the Red Sox have set the template for how to handle moody superstars who demand or receive maximum free agent money. In the case of the Cardinals, they relinquished free agent superstar Albert Pujols to the Angels and received back a draft choice which they used to acquire Michael Wacha, who as a rookie has been the best pitcher in the playoffs. In 2012, the Red Sox cut their losses and traded Josh Beckett, Carl Crawford, and Adrian Gonzalez to the Dodgers, shedding 240 million in payroll in the process, and used the money saved to acquire five middle tier free agents who have played major roles in their march to the World Series.

The Cardinals are almost entirely built from the draft. Five key players on their World Series roster derive from their 2009 draft alone, including two starters (Joe Kelly, Shelby Miller), closer Trevor Rosenthal, lead-off man Matt Carpenter, and clean-up hitter Matt Adams. Beyond Rosenthal, the rest of the bullpen is comprised primarily of rookie pitchers. In Game 2 of the NLCS, a game started by Wacha, 26 of 27 outs were recorded by rookie pitchers, and in the 13-inning Game 1 marathon, 29 of the first 30 outs were registered by rookies. Ace starter Adam Wainwright is also home-grown.

In the early 1990’s, the Yanks’ farm system was strong, giving rise to Jeter, Rivera, Pettitte, Bernie Williams, and Jorge Posada. Not coincidentally, this was during the period of George Steinbrenner’s 2-year suspension from baseball. Twenty years of pursuing high-priced free agents and neglecting the draft cannot be overcome by an overnight change of heart.

But saying no to Cano would be a good place to start.


AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Rooting for A-Rod

August 19th, 2013 sendarama Posted in baseball 1 Comment »

You know who you are.

You’re recognizable in a frenzied crowd because you’re the only one not cheering. You hate all things trite. You cringe when a stranger says “Have a good one.”

Were you of a different age, you’d have condemned HUAC, rooted for the Loyalists, and cheered Muhammad Ali when he refused to step forward for induction. You’re the dopey kid who came to Will Kane’s aid in “High Noon” when the whole town had deserted him. You’re against mob rule. You can’t resist an underdog.

You’re A-Rod fan.

Following six weeks of public revilement which would have caused other national disgraces (Tonya Harding, Steve Bartman, OJ Simpson, to name a few) to run for cover, Alex Rodriguez has been unwavering. You are impressed by his steadfastness and calm under pressure. You know that under similar circumstances, you would crumble like a Ritz cracker. You don’t like Bud Selig, and you can’t help feeling that he is attempting to destroy A-Rod’s career for the purpose of burnishing his legacy.

You’re A-Rod fan

You don’t like that A-Rod was singled out for punishment far beyond the fifty-game suspensions levied on eleven other similarly-situated players, and you’re turned off by the faux praise lobbed at Ryan Braun by MLB brass when he copped an early plea to a 65-game suspension. You think that whiners like John Lackey who “wants back” a home run he surrendered to A-Rod ten years ago are hypocrites because they played with other admitted steroid users. And why should players be upset about A-Rod for exercising the appeal rights available to all players under the Joint Drug Agreement?

You can’t help thinking that MLB is trying to discredit A-Rod by the systematic leaking of information suggesting that he interfered with MLB’s investigation of the Biogenesis clinic and divulged information about other alleged users to the press. These events, if true, occurred several months ago during a bidding war between MLB and A-Rod for Biogenesis evidence. Leave it to the arbitrator, you say, to decide whether such activities warrant extra punishment. Despite MLB’s holier than thou stance, you know that this is not obstruction of justice, that this is not a criminal investigation.

You’re A-Rod fan

And you’re appalled that Rod is being targeted by other pitchers with beanballs, and that fans are cheering when he gets hit. It happened in Chicago last week; and last night, Ryan Dempster hurled four consecutive pitches at A-Rod before nailing him in the back as Boston fans exploded with glee. You thought Dempster should have been tossed, but it turned out for the best when A-Rod turned on the pathetic Dempster two at bats later and smashed his weak serving on a line over the centerfield bleachers, spurring an important victory.

You’re A-Rod fan.

If you are a Yankee fan, then you never abandoned A-Rod in the first place, because team fandom trumps the peccadillos of any particular player. A-Rod’s return from a season-long injury has already sparked the Yankees to improved play over his first twelve games. If he can somehow lead them into the playoffs, his pitfalls with PED’s will be a mere footnote to the Yankees’ most remarkable comeback since 1978.

You’re Yankee fan and A-Rod fan.

You’re isolated because the powers that be are aligned against the beleaguered slugger; and everyone you talk to thinks A-Rod is a sleaze and should have the book thrown at him. But you sense that subtly, gradually, public opinion is shifting in A-Rod’s favor. The bombastic Steven A. Smith praised A-Rod’s “intestinal fortitude.” You can’t help but appreciate his focus under tremendous pressure, noted another commentator. His inspired performance last night may well mark a turning point for the Yankees and for A-Rod’s reputation, said Mark Schlereth of ESPN. Even those who detest A-Rod must be saying to themselves, “That guy sure can compartmentalize.”

Dempster plunks A-Rod.

In the build-up to A-Rod’s suspension, few came to his defense. Not even the Yankee front office offered support. Following a public dispute with A-Rod over whether he was ready to come back from injury, Yankee GM Brian Cashman told him to “shut the fuck up.” Later, the Yankees extended A-Rod’s re-hab past the point when his suspension was likely to be announced. Several talk show hosts predicted he would never again play for the Yankees. Even the Yankees’ beat writer for the New York Times, Tyler Kepner, lashed out at Rodriguez’ poor character and weak-mindedness.

And the rift between team and player will only get deeper now that A-Rod’s new counsel, brash celebrity lawyer Joseph Tacopina, has accused the Yankees of “running an invalid” onto the field last fall with knowledge of A-Rod’s hip injury. He will recommend , he said, that A-Rod agree to “not one inning of suspension.” With the revelation that Rodriguez is planning to file a grievance against the Yankees based on faulty medical treatment, Cashman fired back that A-Rod was a liar because he had previously told him (Cashman) that the Yankee doctors were fine. Rodriguez’ camp appears to be laying the foundation for a lawsuit against MLB and the Yankees alleging a conspiracy to ruin A-Rod’s career. Relations between team and player could not be worse.

Has any athlete felt such combined heat from Team, League and Public while still competing? Lance Armstrong was retired when his world came undone. And when has a team so publicly trashed its own player? Not since George Steinbreener hired gambler Howard Spira to gather dirt against Dave Winfield in the 80’s have the Yankees so turned on one of their own. And that was in secret.

It’s been said that some star athletes feel empowered when playing in a hostile environment. If so, can you imagine how pumped A-Rod gets going up against the World? Against this backdrop of hostility, A-Rod is playing well and he’s galvanized the Yanks into playing better. The team as a whole is hitting 60 points above its team average since A-Rod’s return August 5th.

Of course, it’s the magnitude of A-Rod’s contract which puts the Yanks in a quandary. If they cut him, they eat 86 million over four years. And they can’t trade him. At this point, it’s hard to know what they want. Do they wish A-Rod to recover his lost magic and be a productive player for the balance of his contract, or would they prefer that the arbitrator uphold the 211- game suspension and free them from liability for that period? As the tension between team and player continues to heat up, it appears that they are opting for the latter result.

Yes, A-Rod has made problems for himself by lying about his steroid use on national television, and by being unmindful of the impact of his conduct on his image. By allowing himself to be photographed kissing himself in the mirror, by sunbathing naked in Central Park, by slipping his phone number to an attractive blonde while on the bench during last year’s playoffs, and by a host of other tone-deaf acts, he has left the indelible perception that he is selfish, narcissistic, and self-absorbed.

All of that may be true. But that does not equate to making him the poster boy for steroid use.

While his legal team mounts open challenges to MLB and the Yankees, A-Rod sticks to his mantra: “My focus is on playing well and winning games.” If he continues to translate that theme into results on the field, he will mount his best case. Five weeks from now, if A-Rod is batting 320, with ten home runs, and 30 rbi’s, and the Yanks are in the thick of the wild card race, then he will have done more for his cause than all the posturing by his lawyers. Even the skeptical public will come to appreciate his grace under pressure. When and if that happens, the stage will be set for a negotiated reduced suspension, say 60 games, that A-Rod can accept.

Until then, A-Rod fan will watch every game, savor every at-bat, and yearn for heroic acts.

Here’s rooting for you, A-Rod.

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Back to Earth….. with a Thud

October 24th, 2012 sendarama Posted in baseball No Comments »

As the Giants and Tigers square off in the World Series, my thoughts turn to what might have been…

A Nats season ticket holder since 2005 and a Yankee fan since birth, I woke up two weeks ago pulsating at the prospect of the best baseball week, or fortnight, of my life. And it was not inconceivable that this magical stretch might culminate in a Yanks-Nats World Series, with me ticketed behind first base with four tickets to the Greatest Show on Earth. Friends I’d written off for dead were inquring about my health.

The tune on the tips of my tongue that Monday morning was “I’m in Heaven, I’m in Heaven, and my heart beats so that I can barely speak. And I seem to find the happiness we seek, when we’re out together dancing cheek to cheek.”

It’s been seventy seven years since the lovestruck Fred Astaire croooned these Irving Berlin lyrics to Ginger Rogers in “Top Hat,” but substitute the horsehide sphere for Rogers’ deep blue eyes, and you capture how I felt. Little did I know that five days later I’d be mouthing “Heartbreak Hotel” (for the Nats), and that not long after, I’d be writing script for the Yanks’ dynasty tombstone,

Going in, both teams were the short favorites in their league to make it to the World Series, but for different reasons. The Yanks, playoff participants in seventeen of the past eighteen years, were riding their reputation. The Nats, the first Washington team to play in October since 1933, had the best team.

And the respective Divisional Series began so promisingly. The Nats squeezed out a 3-2 victory over the Cards with a two-out eighth inning bleeder by pinch hitter Tyler Moore and a decisive save by closer Drew Storen. The Yanks broke open a 2-2 game in Baltimore with five runs in the top of the ninth inning. All was well.

With the prospect of attending six playoff games in one week, I drove to Baltimore Monday night for game 2 of the ALDS. Baltimore fans were giddy. The O’s having so unexpectedly made the playoffs, the fans were running on house money. Everything was great. No worries. And why should there be? The O’s were 31-10 in 1-run games. They had won an incredible 16 straight in extra innings.

The Yanks spurted out of the gate in Game 2. A walk to Jeter and a single by Ichiro set the table for A-Rod. In an at-bat which set the tone for his playoff failures, the fading superstar ripped a liner over second base, surely destined for center field. But Andino made a diving grab and flipped to second for the double play. Instead of one run in, no out, first and third, it was two out and a runner on first. The Yanks eked out a first inning run on an acrobatic slide by Ichiro after a double by Teixeira, but Andino’s play saved a big inning. Andy Pettitte had less than his best stuff, and the O’s clawed their way to a 3-2 win, tying the series at 1-1 and their season series with the Yanks at 10-10.

After a game 2 drubbing in St.Louis to tie the series, the Nats returned home Wednesday to a sundrenched day before an adoring crowd. The 1:00 start was reminiscent of the World Series games of my youth. All that was missing was the black and white TV flickering in the appliance store. It was an idyllic setting punctuated by a glorious rendition of the national anthem and the roar of the Navy Seals flying overhead just before first pitch. Despite the newness of the surroundings to the young Nats, particularly when compared to the battle-tested Cards, few at Nats Park seriously doubted the ability of the homestanders to prevail.

With Edwin Jackson on the mound, the crowd stood up on every 2-strike pitch, no matter the count, no matter the score. In New York, they know to withhold these bursts of frenzy until there are two outs. But the not ready for prime time DC fans knew no such limitations. When the Cards burst to an early 5-0 lead, the exuberance seemed out of place. At 8-0, the practice became downright annoying. Belying its naivete, the crowd even cheered negative plays, as when La Roche bounded into a force at second with one out and runners on first and second.

With the Nats’ backs to the wall for Game 4, tension heightened for Thursday’s 4:00 tilt. Crowd merriment subsided, replaced by fear. As the sun turned to shadows, and the thrill mixed with chill, there ensued the most gripping game of the Nats 2012 season. In the second inning, against Cardinal ace Kyle Lohse, LaRoche ignited the crowd, first with a foul homer, then with a real one. The 1-0 lead lasted only an instant, thanks to an infield error by Desmond. Lohse and Detwiler matched zeroes through the sixth when the Nats bullpen took over. Nat relievers Zimmerman, Clippard, and Storen struck out eight of the next nine batters.Then Jason Werth faced Lance Lynn to lead off the ninth.

The most overpriced player in the majors, A-Rod excepted, Werth had received a pass this year. Since returning from a wrist injury which sidelined him from April to August, Werth batted leadoff and eked out a .300 average. With five sluggers following him in the lineup and the team successful, Nat fans were inclined to overlook Werth’s pathetic power numbers (5 hr, 31 rbi). And what happened next probably extended his grace period into next June. After a 13-pitch at bat, including at least three feeble popups which barely made their way into the stands, Werth met a Lynn fast ball just right and sent it soaring into the visitor’s bullpen in left field. The stage was set for game five Friday night.

To the north, the Bronx Bombers, now known as the Bronx Peashooters, were suffering a power outage which threatened to end their season prematurely. Several of the Yanks’ big guns – A-Rod, Cano, Swisher and Granderson- had become strikeout machines, as in “all they do is strike out.” These four, who earned 65 million/annum, combined to strike out 44 times in 125 at-bats times in the playoffs while batting to a collective .112 (14-125). In the words of Yank commentator Ken Singleton, they were “lost at the plate,” their indecision reflected in a flurry of checked swings.

In the case of Cano and Swisher, the problem was of sudden onset. Cano had closed the season on a 24-39 tear and Swisher had finished at a fast clip. But with A-Rod, the problems appeared to be of a more serious nature. Since returning from a hand injury in early September, the once-dangerous slugger had been helpless against right-handers, resembling a Punch and Judy hitter more than the compiler of 647 home runs.

By game three, the savvy New York crowd had already lost its patience with this group of over-swinging sluggers. At Nats Park and Camden Yards, it was sardine room only; but at the Stadium, throughout the playoffs, rows of empty seats were visible behind home plate and in the lower levels. The Yanks’ stirring 12-inning triumph in game 3, on two Raul Ibanez home runs, and their eventual victory over the O’s in five games, did nothing to quell the general uneasiness about the team’s prospects.

Game Five for the Nats, a game which will live in infamy, could not have begun better. Before the foam had subsided on the evening’s first beer, the Nats had plated three runs off Card starter Adam Wainwright – a double by Werth, a triple by Harper, and a booming homer by Zimmerman. Then, in the third, they took a 6-0 lead on homers by Harper and Morse. It would take the greatest collapse in a deciding game in Major League history for the Nats to lose this one. On the Win Expectancy Meter, the Nats enjoyed a 96.3% probability of success.

But that statistiic did not factor in a lack of playoff maturity and a slew of managerial miscues by Davey Johnson. When starter Gio Gonzalez walked four batters leading to three runs before being yanked, the Cards had crawled to 6-3. Johnson’s first mistake was leaving Gonzalez in too long. Then, he brought in starter Edwin Jackson for relief for the seventh inning instead of regular reliever Ryan Mattheus. The combustible Jackson was an odd choice since he had been shelled in Game 3 Wednesday and was not accustomed to relieving. He was lucky to escape with only one run allowed. When Clippard allowed a home run to light-hitting Descalzo in the eighth, the margin became razor thin; but an insurance run in the bottom of the eighth restored the win expectancy to a healthy 96.5% entering the top of the 9th.

With closer Drew Storen on the mound with a 2-run lead, the Nats could not have asked for better positioning. Even after Carlos Beltran’s lead-off double, Storen retired the next two batters and had two strikes on Yadier Molina with Beltran on third. The crowd stoked to a frenzy. Strangers were slapping five and exchanging hugs. Then, Storen became over-cautious and walked Molina. After several more 2-strike counts, he did the same with Freese. After the pesky Descalso poked a game-tying single to center off Desmond’s glove, Johnson chose to pitch to shortstop Kozma rather than to issue an intentional walk to bring up the pitcher’s spot, occupied by closer Jason Motte, who had already pitched the 8th inning. To creep back, the Cards had already burned their primary pinch hitters, and they had no one reliable in the bullpen.

But Johnson chose to pitch to Kozma, whose line single to right field dashed the Nats’ hopes, and season. After having been hailed as a wizard all year long, Johnson’s instincts had failed him. In game 5, everything he tried went wrong. His mistakes will be part of a legacy which will last until the Nats achieve post-season success.

In the Bronx, the aftertaste was just as sour. The Tigers 4-game sweep left the Yanks in disarray and with many decisions to make in the off-season. At least, the Nats can rely on the quality of their roster and the depth of their pitching staff to look promisingly to next season.

It’s a long plunge from baseball heaven to the double whammy inflicted on my Yanks and Nats – a devastating deciding game defeat followed by an humiliating 4-game sweep. It’s enough to make one turn to football. Does anybody need World Series tickets?

But enough with the mourning. It’s back to the future….. San Francisco in six.

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Pettitte to the Rescue…….Again

September 18th, 2012 sendarama Posted in baseball No Comments »

In Andy Pettitte’s long history with the Yankees, reaching back to 1995 and including 206 wins and 38 post-season appearances, he has never been their number one man. Though Pettitte has been a Yankee starter longer than anybody not named Ford or Ruffing, he has always played second or third fiddle in the rotation – to David Cone, David Wells, Mike Mussina, Roger Clemens, and more recently, CC Sabathia. Even AJ Burnett was slotted ahead of Pettitte in 2009 and 2010.

But if he hasn’t been the Yanks’ top dog over the years, Pettitte has certainly been their rescue dog. For most of his 14 years with the Bombers, including tonight, when he will take the mound against Toronto at the Stadium after a three-month layoff with a broken ankle, Pettitte has been a veritable St. Bernard for the Yankees in critical situations, whether it be the second game of a playoff series in which they trailed (4 times), the deciding game of a playoff series (3 times), the fifth game of a tied World Series (1996), or to salvage a season and pitching staff spiraling out of control, such as right now.

Make no mistake. The Yanks are getting by on fumes. Since July 18, when they led the American League East by 10 games with a majors-best record of 57-34, they have gone 26-29. Between August 15th and September 13th, they did not win two consecutive games.

You could make the argument that putting aside a six week stretch from June 3 to July 18, when they went 29-10, the Yanks have been a sub-500 team for seventy five percent of the season. Contrast the Nationals, who have posted a winning record for each month.

Despite an uptick in the past few days, the Yanks’ starting pitching has been a wreck, their bullpen a shambles; and despite leading the majors in home runs, their regular lineup has been startlingly unable to hit with runners in scoring position or to move runners around the bases. Of the ten Yankee hitters who have stroked ten dingers or more, all of them hit less with RISP than otherwise. The averages dip even further with RISP + two outs.

Furthermore, their running game has disappeared. Last year, with Brett Gardner and Eduardo Nunez playing major roles, they featured a nice mix of speed and power. This year, Gardner has been injured, and Nunez spent most of the season in the minors. They are pure station to station.

Andy Pettitte as a dog

For Yankee fans, such as this writer, it’s become fashionable during late season slumps to foretell the end of their run, which has included sixteen post-season appearances in the last seventeen years. But historically, no team has been more resilient at season’s end than the Bombers. Nor a better front runner. They have never blown a lead of six games or more to lose a pennant or divisional title. Twenty eight times they led the field by ten games or more.

So what makes this Yankee team different?

In the words of one baseball analyst, “they have no strengths as a team other than their ability to hit home runs.”

A former strength, the bullpen, has been reduced to mediocrity by the year-long absence of Mariano Rivera due to injury, and the regression of David Robertson, who handled the eighth inning so superbly a year ago. If a Yankee starter should work through the sixth, the seventh and eighth innings are a crap shoot. Among Boone Logan, Cody Eppley, Clay Rapada, and Joba Chamberlain, there is no one capable of pitching a clean inning. Rafael Soriano has been an effective substitute for Rivera as closer, but it’s just a matter of time before the mercurial Dominican implodes in a big spot.

The Yanks’ starting lineup is old, averaging 34 years. Their bench is aged (Chavez 34, Jones 35, Ichiro 38, and Ibanez 40). While other contenders have incorporated contributing young players into their mix, the Yanks have unveiled no new blood. And there appears to be little help in the farm system. Top pitching prospects Manny Banueles and Dellin Betances have endured disastrous seasons, and there is no non-pitcher on the expanded 40-man roster who is likely to make a difference, other than Nunez, whose ground ball error Friday night was costly.

Complicating matters for the Yankees, in a season with more plot twists than a full year of “Twilight Zones,” is the surreal play of the Orioles, who remain a threat to win the AL East. And under the new rules, the loser in the AL East race, although a near-certain wild card entry, will be at a severe disadvantage. The second-place finisher will play at Oakland in a one-game elimination, and if prevailing, will then face tough Texas in the ALDS. The AL East champ will face easier Chicago or Detroit with home field advantage.

The Orioles, with more runs surrendered than scored, and with a 27-8 record in 1-run games, have defied explanation in compiling an 83-64 won lost record. Last Saturday at Camden Yards against New York, the Birds started three players batting less than .200 and won the game on an horrendous call at first base. They edged Tampa Bay twice last week in showdown games in extra innings. Over the course of the season, Manager Showalter has scrapped four of his original five starters and has mixed and matched among his regulars to fashion a young, energetic squad which is full of surprises.

Looking at their lineup, it’s still hard to take them seriously, but the standings say otherwise.

Enter Pettitte, in circumstances eerily similar to 2010, when having been sidelined for two months with a groin injury, he returned on September 19 in time to stabilize the reeling Yanks and lead them to another division title.

This time, Pettitte was retired in 2011, came back in mid May, and only started nine games before going down. He will be on a strict pitch count and cannot be expected to last beyond five innings in his first start and slightly longer in his remaining two or three outings.

Whatever his won-lost record, the symbolic effect of a string of decent performances by the tall lefthander cannot be over estimated. Conversely, if he falls on his face, the Yanks will be devastated.

It’s a heavy burden to place on a 40-year old veteran, one year removed from retirement, just off a serious leg injury.

But on the shoulders of Andy Pettitte, it looks good.

Just Joshin’

Josh Morgan seems to have escaped his fair measure of public excoriation for the ball-throwing penalty he incurred at the end of Sunday’s Redskins-St. Louis game, costing the Skins a chance to win or tie. To anyone not smothered in political correctness, Morgan’s maneuver will live in infamy as one of the dumbest, most inexcusable misdeeds in an athletic endeavor, not to be soon if ever forgotten. Move over Chris Webber, Leon Lett, Jim Marshall, and Fred Merkle. There’s a new moron in the house.

But the reaction from the media has been muted. Morgan was hailed by some commentators for admitting that he “lost control of his emotions.” As if we thought his act was premeditated. Mike Shanahan’s most severe criticism was, “We can’t lose our poise.” The mantra seems to be “We win and lose as a team. One play did not cost us the game.”

Wrong. Morgan’s bonehead maneuver did cost the Redskins the game, and might have turned around their season, in a bad way. It was unforgivable, no matter how chippy the game became. To make matters worse, Morgan told a Washington Post reporter before the game how important it was to not respond to provocateur Courtland Finnegan’s antics. Stupid is as stupid does.

Can you imagine if Mike Ditka or Vince Lombardi coached the Redskins? Their first move would have been to cut Morgan, their second to kick his ass out of town.

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Roger Restored

June 18th, 2012 sendarama Posted in baseball No Comments »

Was the jury verdict in the Roger Clemens case more a comment on the quality of the lawyering than on Clemens’ guilt or innocence?

Does Clemens’ acquittal on all counts restore the righthander to his rightful prominence in the pantheon of great hurlers or will he be perceived, like OJ Simpson, as a guilty athlete who got off?

Clemens was charged with lying before Congress. Did the jury agree with Clemens’ lawyer Rusty Hardin that Congress should never have held hearings on the Mitchell Report, which was a non-governmental operation commissioned and paid for by Major League Baseball?

If we forgive Roger because he went to trial and was acquitted, shouldn’t we afford the same beneficence to other suspected and admitted users who did not receive their day in court, and accept their records without question?

The answers to these questions will evolve over time, but one thing is certain. The Clemens verdict was less a determination that Clemens never used steroids than an expression of distate for the government’s methods and the integrity of its main witness, Brian McNamee.

Clemens is certainly entitled to bask in his victory, and he will claim vindication for his position that he never used steroids or Human Growth Hormone (HGH); but you would have to believe in the tooth fairy to have heard the testimony in this case and conclude that Clemens never touched the stuff.

Because in the words of defense attorney Rusty Hardin, the government’s prosecution of Roger Clemens was a “horrible overreach,” and because all roads of the government’s case lead through McNamee, who was exposed as a more persistent liar than Alibi Ike, the jury felt compelled to side with Clemens – characterized throughout the trial, even by prosecution witnesses, as a man of great talent, character and determination – over an avaricious government and the very sleazy McNamee.

The government based its case against Clemens almost entirely on McNamee, who testified that he injected Clemens with HGH and anabolic steroids on multiple occasions in 1998, 2000, and 2001, first in Toronto when he was employed as a strength coach with the Blue Jays and then while working for the Yankees, who hired him at Clemens’ request in 2000.

As corroboration for McNamee, who has dealt drugs, lied under oath, forged documents, and suffered two DWI convictions during his checkered past, the government offered syringes, vials and cotton balls saved by him for seven years and allegedly containing Clemens’ DNA, and the testimony of former teammate Andy Pettitte that Clemens admitted steroid use to him in 1999 or 2000.

McNamee first told his story to the Mitchell Commission, which was created by MLB in response to pressure from Congress; but Congress was not involved in the investigation. The Mitchell Report was released in December, 2007, naming Clemens as a user. The 7-time Cy Young award winner challenged the Report’s findings publicly, held a press conference, and sued McNamee for Defamation.

The House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform, bruised by Clemens’ challenge to the accuracy of the Mitchell Report, called hearings to investigate the matter and subpoenaed Clemens to testify. Congress didn’t have to do this. Its decision to call Clemens was politically-charged, backed by Democrats and opposed by Republicans.

In depositions before House investigators, and then again before the full committee, Clemens made the statements denying steroid use which gave rise to his indictment two years later for six counts of lying to Congress.

But the threshold issue before the jury was not whether Clemens lied to Congress, or whether he took steroids or HGH but whether the government proved beyond a reasonable doubt that Clemens made the alleged mistatements with criminal intent.

Did the government prove its case on any count beyond a reasonable doubt?

As the quick jury verdict indicates, the prosecution did not come close to meeting its burden. When you consider that a) McNamara was shredded on cross examination by the ultra slick Hardin and acknowledged at least fifteen different instances of mistakes, bad memory or lying during the progression of the case; b) McNamee’s drug paraphernalia exhibit was deemed “hopelessly contaminated” by defense expert Bruce Goldberger; and c) Pettitte admitted on cross examination that he was only “50% certain” that he understood Clemens correctly during their pivotal conversation in 1999-2000, the government’s case became infected with reasonable doubt.

Things went south early for the feds when former and current Yankee Pettitte was called to the stand out of sequence, before McNamee, because of his obligations to the Yankees. Resplendent in a gray pinned-stripe suit, tanned and lean, the left-hander glowed like a movie star. ‘What a dreamboat,” purred a woman attorney in the courtroom.

Pettitte was deemed vital to the case against Clemens because unlike McNamee, he was a churchgoer and family man and had a reputation for truthfulnes. Compared to McNamee, he was Abe Lincoln. Pettitte had admitted his own steroid use to the Mitchell investigators, and because of his strong religious convictions, had felt compelled to tell the truth about Clemens despite their close relationship.

It was high theatre to see these celebrated Yankees squaring off in Courtroom 6. Five years ago, who could have imagined this scenario?

On direct examination, Pettitte seemed uncomfortable, but he testified consistently with the affidavit he had provided the Mitchell people, namely that Clemens had admitted steroid use to him during a work-out session in Clemens’ home gym in 1999 or 2000. But Pettitte did not want to be the one to send his buddy Roger up the river. He’d been sandbagged by the feds, but damned if he was going to make it easy for them.

Sensing Pettitte’s vulnerability, defense attorney Mike Attanasio, imported by Hardin’s firm to assist in the case, chipped away at the level of Pettitte’s certainty. “Is it fair to say that there’s a 50-50 chance that you misunderstood Clemens,” asked Attanasio. “That’s fair,” said Pettitte.

Petttitte had slipped the feds a curve that was nastier than any of the low and away sliders he used to befuddle Bryce Harper Saturday in Washington. Prosecutor Steven Durham attempted to repair the damage on re-direct, but the lasting image of Pettitte’s testimony is that it was “insufficiently definitive,” in the words of Judge Reggie Walton.

McNamee subsequently told his story, but by the time Hardin finished with him, McNamee was dismayed, disheveled, and discredited. The defense then presented 21 witnesses (not including Clemens) who effectively rebutted every allegation of the indictment. Attanasio and Hardin outclassed the government lawyers during closing argument.

Four and one half years after his ordeal began, Roger Clemens has put his legal problems behind him. It has been estimated that his legal fees to the Hardin firm are between ten and twenty million dollars.

His freedom assured, his legacy restored, his ticket to the Hall of Fame punched, Clemens probably thinks he got a bargain.

* * ** * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *


Nats’ manager Davie Johnson is considered a premier game strategist and one of the best skippers in the game, but overlooked in the Yanks’ sweep of the Nats this weekend was a managerial miscue by Johnson that arguably cost Washington a victory in Saturday’s 14-inning second game of the series.

With the game knotted at 2-2 in the Yanks’ top of the sixth, Jordan Zimmerman was scheduled to face number 8 hitter Eric Chavez with two out and a runner on first. On deck was starter Andy Pettitte, who had a low pitch count through five innings and was projected to pitch at least through the seventh. Zimmerman pitched to Chavez who ripped a double to right center that drove in the lead run.

Though conventional wisdom is that you should not intentionally walk a runner into scoring position, the more creative, and correct, move here would have been to walk Chavez and force Yankee manager Joe Girardi to make a choice – Let Pettitte bat or pinch hit. In the first case, Zimmerman would be facing a weak-hitting pitcher rather than the dangerous Chavez. In the second case, Pettitte is out of the game.

Because Girardi emphasizes getting distance from his starters, the guess here is that he would have let Pettitte bat in a tie game rather than be forced to go to his bullpen early. Johnson, regrettably, did not force Girardi to choose.

The next day, Nat fans and sports talkers alike complained that the bad call on the play at the plate in the eighth inning cost the Nats the game. There was no discussion of Johnson’s decision to pitch to Chavez, but there should have been.


AddThis Social Bookmark Button